Was Fidel Castro A Good Leader?

An estimated 33000 political executions were carried out from 1958 to 1987. These are the atrocities of Fidel Castro’s Cuba. Castro is both loved and loathed. People in Cuba lineup to see just a photographic tribute to him while people in Miami are celebrating in the streets. Fidel Castro ran Cuba under a Marxist-Leninist system, nationalizing businesses and implementing state socialist reforms. So was Fidel Castro a good leader for Cuba? The answer is no. With human rights abuses under his watch, thousands fleeing his regime, and the failure of the Cuban economy, I can assuredly say that Fidel Castro was not a good leader.

Fidel Castro in Washington - Creative Commons License
Fidel Castro in Washington  (Creative Commons)

From mass killings to concentration camps Fidel Castro is no stranger to human rights abuses. Mass killings seem like a trend around communist dictators, with 45 million killed in Mao’s great leap forward to the 20 million killed by Stalin. Fidel Castro is no stranger to mass killings, with an estimated 4000 to 33000 executions, where policemen and rival politicians were the majority of those executed. Political repression is also widespread in Cuba, a report by Human rights Watch showed that “scores of political prisoners arrested by Fidel continue to languish in political prisons”  Castro had even acknowledged that he held 15000 political prisoners in 1964. The Cuban government has also installed methods of internal surveillance to observe and control dissidents while controlling the media, which is probably the reason why Cuba ranks at the bottom of the press freedom index.

Fidel Castro speaking in Washington - Creative Commons License
Fidel Castro speaking in Washington.  Photo courtesy of Creative Commons License

For decades, Cubans have been trying to sail to the US and swim ashore before immigration agents catch up with them.  Those who make it past the US Coast Guard and reach the shores the United States are given legal admission. Thousands of people have run out of money, paying traffickers tens of thousands of dollars to get them to the US land border, and more than 1.5 million Cubans have fled from Cuba to the United States. Before the 1980s, many of the people fleeing Cuba were those who feared political reprisal after the communist takeover, but another group of Cuban refugees that came to the United States came in the 80s in a time called the Mariel Boatlift. Those fleeing Cuba during the Mariel Boatlift were mainly economic migrants, fleeing Cuba’s dying economy. Many of the Cuban refugees oppose Castro’s communist rule and have since created groups like the Cuban-American Lobby which supports the US embargo against Cuba as well as pressing the communist government of Cuba’s for change.

Fidel Castro meets German Navy men - Creative Commons License
Fidel Castro meets German Navy men, courtesy of Creative Commons 

Despite many people talking about the so-called legacy of Castro, they choose to ignore the state of disaster that Cuba’s economy is in. According to Forbes, in 1959 when Castro took power, the GDP per capita for Cuba was $2,067 a year —about the same as Ecuador ($1,975), Jamaica ($2,541), Panama ($2,322) and two-thirds of Puerto Rico ($3,239).  40 years later, Cuba has advanced hardly at all, to $2,307, while Ecuador has jumped to $3,809, Jamaica to $3,670, Panama to $5,618 and Puerto Rico to $13,738. This only illustrates how Cuba’s economy hasn’t advanced since Castro first took power. The average state salary per month in Cuba 471 pesos which is 20 dollars and according to a Bloomberg article, “As for industrial production, the country’s output remains below half of its pre-1989 levels. Rates of savings and investment are at about 10 percent, about half of Latin American averages, and the legal framework is hostile to direct foreign investment.”

Fidel Castro was not a good leader and, with his death and the promise of the current leader of Cuba Raul Castro to step down after his 2nd term, we can only hope that Cuba will embark on the road to change that it deserves.

Author: Kai Suherwan

Kai Suherwan is a Junior and his second year writing for The Eye. He is seen as the Republican/Conservative writer in The Eye and has been at SAS since 7th grade. He is heavily involved in Republican politics, enjoys discussing current events and hopes to work in the field foreign affairs one day. He can be contacted at: Suherwan45031@sas.edu.sg

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s